The father of a young gang-rape survivor has strongly criticised West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee over her recent remark on the incident. The rape case, which has shocked the state and attracted national attention, occurred in Nadia district earlier this month. The father’s comments have added another layer to an already sensitive and polarising debate.

The survivor, a teenager, was allegedly assaulted by a group of men in a remote area before being hospitalised. The crime has sparked outrage among women’s rights activists, opposition parties, and ordinary citizens across India. Police have arrested several suspects, and investigations are continuing.

Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee recently made a statement that appeared to question certain details of the case. While she condemned crimes against women, she also suggested that the truth behind some cases may be more “complex” than what is reported immediately. This remark drew sharp criticism from several quarters, with many accusing her of being insensitive towards victims.

Speaking to reporters, the survivor’s father said he was “hurt and shocked” by Mamata Banerjee’s comments. He stressed that his daughter has suffered immensely, both physically and emotionally, and needs support rather than doubt.

“My child has been through a terrible nightmare. What she needs now is compassion and justice, not political statements that make her pain worse,” he said.

He urged the Chief Minister to meet with the family and understand their struggles firsthand. “If she sees the condition of my daughter, she will realise what has happened. This is not about politics, it’s about humanity,” he added.

Mamata Banerjee’s remark has reignited a long-standing debate about the balance between verifying facts and showing empathy to victims of sexual violence. While her office has clarified that she was referring to the need for thorough investigations, critics argue that public leaders have a responsibility to choose their words carefully.

Activists are quick to point out that public comments from politicians can influence the atmosphere in which survivors speak out. “When a leader questions a victim’s account, it can discourage others from coming forward,” said a Kolkata-based women’s rights advocate.

Opposition parties have seized upon Banerjee’s statement to criticise her government’s record on handling crimes against women. Some have accused her administration of failing to provide adequate protection and support for survivors.

Meanwhile, social media is flooded with mixed reactions. Hashtags calling for justice for the survivor are trending, while others debate whether political leaders should comment before the completion of investigations.

This incident highlights how words from powerful figures can affect public sentiment, especially in cases involving trauma. While ensuring a fair investigation is necessary, empathy for victims should remain at the forefront. In such sensitive cases, political leaders might do better to express solidarity alongside a commitment to uncovering the truth.

For the survivor and her family, the road to justice will be long and challenging. As the investigation proceeds, the hope remains that society and leaders alike will prioritise compassion over controversy.

With inputs from agencies

Image Source: Multiple agencies

© Copyright 2025. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Vygr Media.